Grey Eyeliner Pencil

Isaac Parker
11 min readMar 30, 2024

--

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-1

Welcome to our Grey Eyeliner Pencil roundup! If you’re a fan of grey eyeliner and always on the lookout for the perfect pencil, then you’re in the right place. Here, we’ve gathered a range of top-quality grey eyeliner pencils, perfect for achieving that smoky eye or subtle, everyday look. Get ready to explore and discover your new favorite pencil. Let’s dive in!

The Top 5 Best Grey Eyeliner Pencil

  1. Define Your Eyes with L’Oreal Paris Superliner Le Smoky Grey Eyeliner Pencil — Experience the flawless smoky eyes with L’Oreal Paris Superliner Le Smoky, a dual-ended eyeliner pencil that easily defines and blends for any desired look.
  2. Long-Lasting Cruelty-Free Grey Eyeliner Pencil for Intense Eyes — Intensify your eyes with a long-lasting, cruelty-free vegan grey eyeliner pencil that defines beauty and offers a smudge-proof effect.
  3. Long-Wear Grey Eye Pencil from IL Makiage — Experience the unbeatable “Long Wear Eye Pencil” by IL Makiage, offering a professional-grade, smudge-proof, and waterproof formula, perfect for your daily makeup routine!
  4. Sleek and Creamy Waterproof Grey Eyeliner Pencil for 12 Hour Intensity — Get ready to rock your eyes with Sephora Collection Waterproof 12hr Retractable Eyeliner Pencil in Shimmer Slate Gray, offering incredible intensity and a rich shimmer!
  5. Intensely Pigmented Blue-Gray Quickliner by Clinique — Experience intensive color with Clinique Quickliner for Eyes, a smudge-free, long-lasting eyeliner in a richly pigmented shade of 08 Blue Grey, complete with a no-sharpening smudge tool.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reviews

Define Your Eyes with L’Oreal Paris Superliner Le Smoky Grey Eyeliner Pencil

lor-al-paris-superliner-le-smoky-various-shades-mystic-grey-1

The L’Oreal Paris Superliner Le Smoky is a wonder to behold, an eyeliner with a dual-ended design expertly crafted for stunning, long-lasting colors on your eyes. With a sleek precision pencil and an attached smudger, creating those striking smoky looks is a piece of cake.

The defining feature of this eyeliner is the combination of oil and wax in the formula which allows you to blend and create perfect smoky eye looks. No smudger tool necessary! The stylus is simple to use, applying to the lids for a crisp line or blending for a sultry, smoldering effect that’s perfect for your dark sultry nights out.

In my experience, I loved that this eyeliner is ophthalmologically tested, ensuring safe delivery into your eyes. The smoothness of the pencil gliding across the lids was impressive, offering a rich vibrancy of color that’s hard to find in such a small form. It held up beautifully without smudging around the eyes, giving me the perfect smoky look for days.

However, the smudging brush tip seemed superfluous to me. It might work for some, but personally, I prefer using a swipe of shadow or some extra mascara to achieve the smoky smudge look. The only downside was a slight stiffness to the smudger brush, making it impossible for me to fully utilize it. But that’s really a very minor criticism in the grand scheme of things.

Overall, the L’Oréal Paris Superliner Le Smoky lived up to its name, delivering a fantastic, sultry eyeliner that’s as easy to use as it is to love.

Long-Lasting Cruelty-Free Grey Eyeliner Pencil for Intense Eyes

e-l-f-no-budge-retractable-eyeliner-charcoal-1

I had the pleasure of trying the e. l. f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner Charcoal in my daily life, and let me tell you, it was an experience! The first thing that stood out to me was the creamy pigmentation of this eyeliner. It applied smoothly and effortlessly to my lash line, giving me a bold and intense look that lasted all day long. This pencil liner checked all my requirements — it was waterproof, smudge-proof, and the retractable feature made it so easy to use.

Now, let me address the downsides of this product. I found that the eyeliner tended to smudge a little too easily under my eyes, especially if I blinked or rubbed my eyes. However, it did stay in place on my lash line and waterline with minimal touch-ups throughout the day. And while it’s cruelty-free and vegan, some users have reported issues with allergen-friendliness, so it’s something to consider for those with sensitive eyes or skin.

Overall, the e. l. f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner Charcoal met my expectations and provided a bold finish for my eyes. It was easy to use, stayed on all day, and offered an affordable alternative to pricier eyeliners. So, if you’re looking for a cruelty-free and budget-friendly eyeliner, this one might be worth trying!

Long-Wear Grey Eye Pencil from IL Makiage

il-makiage-long-wear-eye-pencil-oreo-1

Using Il Makiage’s Long-Wear Eye Pencil in Oreo for a few weeks, I can confidently say it’s a game-changer for eyeliner lovers. The smudge-proof, waterproof formula holds up beautifully throughout the day, keeping my look fresh and vibrant. The retractable packaging and comfortable, twistable design make application a breeze.

One downside was the cap’s tightness — it took a bit of effort to remove, and I ended up snapping the tip when I did. Thankfully, the pencil is sharpenable, and I was able to use a standard sharpener to fix the issue.

Another minor inconvenience was the lack of a sharpener in the cap, but I managed to find a suitable one elsewhere. Overall, this eye pencil exceeds expectations — the comfortable application and long-lasting color make it a must-have in my makeup routine.

Sleek and Creamy Waterproof Grey Eyeliner Pencil for 12 Hour Intensity

sephora-collection-waterproof-12hr-retractable-eyeliner-pencil-15-shimmer-slate-gray-0-01-oz-0-3-g-1

When I first started using the Sephora Collection Waterproof 12hr Retractable Eyeliner Pencil in Shimmer Slate Gray, it quickly became my go-to eyeliner for a natural, effortless look. The formula is indeed creamy and glides on smoothly, without any flaking or harshness. The built-in sharpener and smudger are handy features too.

However, what truly stood out was the eyeliner’s waterproof nature, which lasted well beyond the day, even on oily lids. I appreciated how the shade blended perfectly on my combination skin tone, intensifying the look without appearing harsh or too heavy.

Yet, there was one feature that I found a bit disappointing — the 12-hour wear claim, which didn’t hold up for me as advertised, especially on my oily skin. The eyeliner did appear creased and splotchy after a long shift.

Despite this minor letdown, I’ve continued to use the Sephora Collection Waterproof 12hr Retractable Eyeliner Pencil in Shimmer Slate Gray, as its overall performance and ease of use outweigh the wear claim for me.

Intensely Pigmented Blue-Gray Quickliner by Clinique

clinique-quickliner-for-eyes-08-blue-grey-0-3gram-0-01ounce-1

As a makeup enthusiast, I recently gave the Clinique Quickliner for Eyes a try in the Blue Grey shade, and I must say, it was quite impressive.

The pigmentation of the liner is rich and bold, perfect for those looking for a dramatic eye look. It glides on smoothly, with little to no effort, making for a seamless application process. One feature I particularly appreciate is the smudge tool attached to the other end of the applicator. Gone are the days of fumbling with pencils, sharpening them to a point. This little tool is quite convenient and an innovative touch to the pencil.

However, one thing I noticed is that the liner tends to smudge quite easily. Despite the convenience offered by its smudge tool, ensuring that the liner stays put for longer periods is quite a challenge. Additionally, as some users pointed out, the price for the product is quite high considering the size of the container.

Overall, the Clinique Quickliner for Eyes is a good buy, but be prepared to invest a bit more and to handle the smudging issue if you decide to go with this product.

Buyer’s Guide

Grey eyeliner pencils are a popular cosmetic must-have that offers an array of eye-catching looks and versatility. Whether used for a subtle smoky eye, a bold winged liner, or a touch of depth, these pencils deliver stunning results. In this buyer’s guide, we’ll explore the key features you should consider when selecting a grey eyeliner pencil, as well as provide essential tips for achieving the best makeup looks.

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-2

Softness of the Pencil

One of the most important factors to consider when shopping for a grey eyeliner pencil is the softness of the lead. A soft pencil glides smoothly across the eyelid, providing a precise and easy-to-apply line. Look for pencils with a high concentration of wax and other emollient ingredients that ensure a creamy texture and effortless application. On the other hand, pencils with a higher degree of graphite content tend to be harder and more prone to breaking or snapping.

Color Intensity and Shade

The color intensity of a grey eyeliner pencil is crucial in achieving the desired smoky or bold look. Choose a pencil with rich and intense color that can be built up to create the desired effect. It’s also essential to consider the shade of the pencil — some shades tend to lean more towards the ash or blue undertones, while others may have more of a charcoal or taupe feel. Depending on your skin undertone and desired effect, select a shade that complements your natural coloring and enhances your look.

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-3

Blend-ability

A good grey eyeliner pencil should be easy to apply and, just as importantly, blend. Blendability is essential for creating soft, natural-looking smoky eye or a seamless winged liner. Look for products with a buttery texture that allows for easy blending, without leaving any harsh lines or pencil marks. Applying a light coat of primer before using your eyeliner pencil can also improve its blendability and ensure a longer-lasting look.

Water Resistance

Water resistance is another key factor to consider when purchasing a grey eyeliner pencil. It is particularly important if you live in a humid environment or plan on spending time outdoors. Look for pencils that have a water-resistant formula that can withstand sweat or tears. Although these pencils may be slightly more expensive, the extra protection they offer will help keep your eyeliner in place for a longer period.

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-4

FAQ

What is a Grey Eyeliner Pencil and how is it used in makeup?

A grey eyeliner pencil is a cosmetic product designed specifically for creating a subtle, smokey eye look. It is typically made of a soft, waxy formula that allows for precise application and easy blending. To use a grey eyeliner pencil, you can start by drawing a thin line along the upper lash line, then smudge it lightly for a softer, more natural appearance. Additionally, the pencil can be used on the lower lash line, inner corner, or along the waterline for a more dramatic or smudgy effect.

Remember to sharpen the pencil regularly to maintain a pointed tip for easier application. Grey eyeliner pencils can be paired with other makeup products such as eyeshadow or mascara to create various eye-catching looks. For best results, always remove makeup thoroughly at the end of the day to prevent irritation and maintain healthy skin.

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-5

What should I look for when choosing a grey eyeliner pencil?

When selecting a grey eyeliner pencil, consider the following factors to ensure you get a high-quality product that suits your needs and preferences. Look for a pencil with a soft, blendable formula that glides easily across the skin. The eyeliner should also have good staying power and be smudge-proof once applied.

Consider the shade of the grey eyeliner pencil, as some may be cooler or warmer-toned. If you prefer a softer, more neutral look, opt for a lighter grey shade. For a more dramatic or smokey eye, choose a darker grey or charcoal shade. Additionally, evaluate the pencil’s packaging for convenience, such as a retractable or twist-up mechanism, as well as any added benefits like moisturizing ingredients or built-in sharpener.

Are grey eyeliner pencils suitable for all skin tones?

Grey eyeliner pencils can be a versatile choice for many skin tones, but the suitability may depend on the specific shade and the individual’s personal preference. Lighter grey shades can be flattering for most skin tones, as they create a subtle, natural-looking line that enhances the eyes without being too overpowering.

For those with a fair complexion, darker grey or charcoal shades can add depth and dimension to their eyes. However, those with olive, medium, or deeper skin tones should be cautious with very dark shades, as they can appear harsh or unflattering. In these cases, it’s best to stick with lighter or medium-toned grey eyeliners to avoid any unwanted drama.

Grey-Eyeliner-Pencil-6

How can I ensure my grey eyeliner pencil application looks smooth and even?

To achieve a smooth and even application of your grey eyeliner pencil, consider the following tips: Start by cleansing and moisturizing your skin to ensure a clean and even canvas. Apply a light layer of primer, if desired, to help the eyeliner pencil stick to the skin and last longer. Use a sharpened pencil for easy application and control.

Begin by drawing a thin line along the upper lash line, starting from the inner corner and working your way outwards. Apply light pressure to the pencil and blend the line gently using a clean, damp makeup sponge or brush to achieve a smudged, smoky effect. Repeat the process on the lower lash line, if desired, for added intensity. Remember to clean your tools regularly and sharpen your pencil as needed to maintain a clean, precise application.

Are there any alternatives to using a grey eyeliner pencil?

Yes, there are several alternatives to using a grey eyeliner pencil for creating a soft and smokey eye look. If you prefer a more traditional application, you can use a grey eyeliner powder or cream formula with a brush or sponge. Alternatively, you can opt for a grey eyeshadow or shadow duo, which can be applied using a smaller brush or your finger for a smudged effect.

Another option is to use a dual-ended eyeliner or eyeshadow pencil, which often includes both a lighter and darker shade in one product. This can be helpful for creating a gradient or ombré effect, with the lighter shade at the inner corner and the darker shade towards the outer corner. For a more precise application, consider using an angled eyeliner brush or a gel eyeliner, which may offer more control and definition.

How should I properly maintain and store my grey eyeliner pencil?

To ensure the longevity and performance of your grey eyeliner pencil, follow these steps for proper maintenance and storage: Store the pencil in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight or heat sources. This will help prevent the pencil from melting or fading over time. Keep the cap tightly secured to protect the tip and prevent any moisture or contaminants from entering the pencil.

If you’ve been using the pencil for a while and notice a buildup of product on the tip, use a clean, damp cloth or makeup remover wipe to gently clean the surface. Remember to keep the pencil sharpened for easy application and a precise tip. Sharpen the pencil regularly using a sharpener specifically designed for eyeliner pencils. Store the sharpener in a separate, cool, and dry location to avoid any damage or contamination.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

--

--